Tuesday, December 4, 2007

Movie Review: Facing the Giants

Facing the Giants is a valiant, noble effort with a lot of potential. However, it misses the mark in some key areas for me.

Facing the Giants is the labor of love of Sherwood Baptist Church in Atlanta, Georgia. It is the brain child of brothers in the congregation, and the fruit of the labor of countless parishoners who volunteered their time and talents.

Spoilers ahead. Please do not read if you do not want the plot and end of the movie spoiled.

That basic premise is a high school football coach takes a ragamuffin team from underdogs to Champions. The pivotal point in their journey through the season is when the coach realizes that his purpose is to glorify God, even on the football field. He teaches his students to pray and to seek to honor God in all that they do, regardless of the outcome. The sub-plot is that the coach and his wife have tried unsuccessfully for years to have children. As you can imagine the end of the movie brings a football title and a quiver full of children for the once-barren couple.

Artistically, the movie is average. The script, acting and filming are all mediocre and indicative of an amateur effort. I struggle with our call to do everything with excellence--this movie is not at all competitive with professional Hollywood productions--and the idea that these kind-hearted people probably did give their best and that is all we can ask.

But what troubled me more was the fact that throughout the story, once the main characters adopted a method of praying, everything thence forth was granted according to their wishes. Though I appreciate the earnestness of faith portrayed, I would have found the film to be more instrumental were there examples of faith persisting even when the answer was still "no."

There is a powerful line in the film where in the coach's wife cries out, "Even if you never give me children, I will still love you." What a challenge! This is never demonstrated however because a few moments later, she is given the news that she is pregnant. Perhaps it is true that in some cases, all that is left for us to do is surrender our hearts completely before He will grant our earnest dreams, but in other cases, complete surrender still yields different results than what we would like.

In the Christian context, there is nothing wrong with the film. I did not find anything to be anti biblical persay. I just thought it was all packaged a little too nicely and I fear that a non Christian might walk away either scoffing at the cheesyness of it, or thinking that God is a genie, ready to grant a man's wish if that man would only say the magic prayer.

All that being said, I do love the amount of love and sacrifice that was so clearly poured in to this movie by its creators, from the directing, to the acting, to the potluck style catering for the cast and crew. No one can ever accuse this company of being less than 100% earnest in their sincere desire to tell a lovely story of God's mercy. It is a very sweet film. And I applaud them enthusiastically for daring to take on a subject in the public eye where the church is normally painfully silent.

Infertile couples who have yet or never to receive an answer of "yes" may find this film painful to watch. Couples who have received a "yes" answer from God may find this affirming and encouraging of their own testimony. I urge anyone who watches it to take it as entertainment, not doctrine or a prescription. I wouldn't avoid it, but I also don't embrace it completely.

Recommended: With reservation


  1. Nice review, I've often heard similar comments to how God may have been portrayed as a genie or wish granter.

    I've found that all of the plots and subplots of the movie are based on true stories with the exception of taking that particular team to the state championship. Otherwise, it's based on true stories but assembled into one storyline.


  2. You hit the review right on. I had a very hard time watching it. It was a great movie with a great message but I walked away wondering what many IF's wonder. Do I not have enough faith? Is that my problem?

  3. Thank you so much for putting that into words! I stopped watching this movie when she received the news that she was pregnant. I watched the rest on another day just to see them with one child and pregnant with another and 2 trophies on the mantel. The whole way it was coming together sickened me. God doesn't always answer yes, even if we have full faith in him. Our will isn't always his but this movie made it seem like he is a genie. Too many good godly men have suffered years of sickness and died. Too many women have went childless but still served God. Too many Christians were/are persecuted for this to be even close to a reality. I'm glad to see that I wasn't the only one who felt this way about this movie. I hope no one goes away from it thinking that it is lack of faith that is keeping them from children. Sometimes it's just not his will.

  4. Christina,

    You bring some good talking points about how God is not a Genie. I agree in that the answer to our prayers isn't always in the affirmative.

    During the scene where Brooke is waiting in the doctors office for yet another pregnancy test, in the room are I believe 2 couples who were told they could never have children. (I discovered this by watching the movie again with the directors comments on) this proved to radically change my opinion of the movie cause I have to admit, it could seem a little syrupy about how everything goes well for everyone just cause they decided to do things God's way. Meaning that this was based on actual real life examples of when God DID answer in the affirmative. The whole movie is full of similar examples of real situations. Like when someone anonymously bought a vehicle for a staff member of the school. I will agree that things like this are rare but keep in mind that this movie is about hope, encouragement, bringing entertainment to families and can not ring true to all viewers of the film.

    I've met many of the people that were involved with this film as well as my wife and I flew from MN and personally checked out the church behind it, Sherwood Baptist in Albany Georgia. When you can see the bigger picture behind this movie, why it was made, how it was made, the coming together of God's servants to make a tool that has undoubtedly reached thousands for Christ, then it's easier to take some of the minor areas of disagreement with a grain of salt.

    This movie has certainly spoken to me as well as thousands of other that have decided to either follow Christ or committed to get to know Him on a deeper level. That is a rare thing in todays entertainment world.

    Thanks for the great comments!